l think Shawn. Even though she has bigger legs and is not as graceful she hits all of her handstands perfectly and does not pile in difficulty. She also has a prettier dismount l think.
Latiya S l was talking about opinion. My opinion was Shawn. Not everyone thinks Nastia is the best.
l was just asking people is opinion is okay. Oh my gosh!
xanta_d you could have your opinion. l was just asking who you though was better on bars. But you do not have to put down my opinion. l was just asking.
All l want is opinion. l know that Nastia is technically better but l personally think Shawn is better. All l want is your own opinion.

l think nastia liukin is better at bars. she hits all the positions perfect. and they even said that she is like one of the best at bars. my opinion.

Nastia without a doubt. Her routine is so much more difficult, her handstands are better than shawn is and her grace is fantastic. It also proves that Nastia is better in competition because she ALWAYS beats Shawn.

Nastia Liukin all the way. She is an amazing gymnast and does an amazing bar routine, she does the most difficult bar routines ever. the lines and toe points she has. and she does it soo gracefull and elegant. and her dismount is awsome.

What kind of question is this? Nastia is an UB specialist. Her start value on bars is 7.7 she is one of only four gymnasts with that start value. Nastia is one of the stars on bars. Plus she is a lot more elegant and graceful.

You can have whatever opinion u want, but the question u asked is not subjective.

You can ENJOY Shawn on bars more, but she absolutely is not BETTER than Nastia on them.

Bars is by far Shawn is weakest event. Her technical shortcomings leave her only able to perform fairly basic moves & the only thing saving her from sub-15 scores is that she can crank out a difficult dismount. She also does not hit all her handstands perfectly. That & catching releases close were one of the things that was killing her already meager scores in Beijing. Not ''piling in'' difficulty is not a stylistic choice. She was training more upgrades, but she could not do them.

Nastia, on the other hand, is an uneven bars phenom with insane talent on the apparatus, one of the world is hardest routines, & the distinction of arguably being the best bar worker in the world.

She is absolutely better on them, regardless of ur personal preference.

Definitely Nastia. She hits all of her handstands perfectly, and she is so graceful on bars. She is one of the 4 gymnasts in the world with a 7.7+ start value. Bars is Shawn is weakest event, and Nastia is best. =D

l honestly think Shawn is better but that is just my opinion. l am with you on that if you watched her in the Olympics she hit all her handstands perfectly. Her dismount l thought that her dismount was way more beautiful. But once again this is my opinion. l no that Nastia is better though l just like to watch Shawn more.

Nastia is better on bars she tied for first with one of the chinese gymnasts shawn is big routine is balance beam

l agree with you, even though nastia won all around or whatever l think Shawn is better, she may not be as gracefull but she is powerful and amazing. She is also amazing on the balence beam, does not even wobble when she does all of those leaps and flips.That is just my personel opinion. l think Shawn is amazing, but nastia is great too.