| Who thinks the Chinese swimmer was on drugs |
 |
|
 |
|
| Message |
|
Alateixe
|  |
|
I am asking for some professional judgement (randome thoughts are welcome too). The Chinese girl Liu Zige who beat Jessic Schipper to win the 200m butterfly improved her PB by 5 seconds to break the world record.
Is such dramatic improvement in results reasonable? If not, what drug can cause a swimmer is performance to improve so much?
|
|
|
Beert
|  |
|
Realistically that much improvement is not possible, without some chemical help. Since she passed her tests you can not say she was using drugs. Well, you can say it, but you can not prove it. The biggest problem with drug cheats is that now anyone who improves is thought to be a cheat also. There are lots of steroids that can assist performance along with HGH, and EPO.
|
|
|
Star Rider
|  |
|
That is an interesting question.
But, Zige was also coached by Schipper is coach, who is one of the best butterfly coaches in the world. A hard training with a great coach in a home court, l think, can produce a world record even with a significant improvement. The doping argument, without any evidence, is out of merit.
|
|
|
User
|  |
|
well now we may not be able to trace a certain drug in a test but in a few years it will probably be proven positive that they cheated.
|
|
|
Coach
|  |
|
She did have an Australian coach to help her technique. Plus the swimsuit do help swimmer swim faster.
|
|
|
Kim
|  |
|
The truth is most athletes are taking some sort of drug and it is not illegal to take them till they find out about them. Athletes are one step ahead of science when it comes to performance enhancing drugs. This is not just the chinese but most olympic athletes take some kind of performance enhancing drug.it is just a matter of scientists discovering it and then having people banned from taking it.
|
|
|
Lostyo
|  |
|
Can the same be said about Michael Phelps?
|
|
|
Bobyer
|  |
|
That is a very interesting question. Finally someone asks a reasonable question about Chinese athletes, not one about their gymnasts.
Anyway, the pool in Beijing was very fast for multiple reasons. The biggest being it is a metre (3 feet) deeper than the average Olympic pool. Most Olympic pools r about 7 feet deep, it was 10. It was also faster because of the way the water flow in & out of the pool worked. It was at the bottom, instead of the sides. There was a few more which l can not remember.
Also with the new Speedo LZR Racer, everybody was lowering their personal bests, albeit not by 5 seconds. l know almost every Canadian record was broke at this event or the Trials, obviously American & Australian records were broken as well. It would make sense this would increase a swimmers chance of winning.
So while normally I'd say she would have to be using performance enhancing drugs to lower her time by 5 seconds, l think it may have just been it was a fast pool, with a fast suit, & the best swim of her life.
|
|
|
Kickshaw
|  |
|
so if an Aussie or American did this would these questions be asked?.. l think not. it would be credited to a terrific performance. from what l saw in the pool there was nothing to suggest the Chinese were cheating.. just improving. considerably so.
|
|
|
Lemon
|  |
|
talent and willpower are her drugs
|
|
|
couzo
|  |
|
Many swimming records were broken at these Games and be seconds too. l doubt she was on drugs. The swimsuit and the pool probably helped.
|
|
|
Callaway
|  |
|
Just because this girl won the gold medal and you assume she is on drug? You are pathetic. What about Michael Phelps ?
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
 |
|
 |
|
| Lates Messages |
Am i too old for gymnastics
How much proteins, fats and minerals does Michael Phelps need in a day when he is at the olympics?
100m sprint time on grass
anyone else notice on how chubby shawn johnson has gotten
why couldnt women compete in olympic games in the past
Where and when do you think the next Olympic will take place
how long to get a roundoff back handspring
how do i go to the olympics for
If they began to do Olympics like they used to would peoples times be faster
Michael Phelps Question
Are you training for the olympics?
how many sled dogs are pulling a musher in a race
what countries won gold, silver and bronze medals in the last three olympic games? ?
Who would win in a fight, Michael Phelps or Kobe Bryant
what was the best thing for 2008 for you and what are you looking forward to this year
whats the name of that really fast jamaican who won gold at the olympics?
What do they do in a sports physical?
Is the olympic games a waste of money? Explain. ??
DO u think NAstia liukin should of gotten gold on bars
Need to find at least 3 female dressage riders
How long to gymnasts train?
Back handspring help!
Mens vault - 2008 olympics
i really want to be able todo the splits
I'm scared to do a back handspring.
must i be able to do standing back handsprings before doing them w/ roundoff
who was the idiot who thought of gymnastics?
when is the 2010 winter games??? (the date) :)?
How old is Jordyn Wieber (the gymnast)?
Is it a disadvantage to pole vault when you're short?
Could a gymnastics team help me get skinney
Will skateboarding ever be part of the olympics
What are some [Olympic] sports where jumping is involved?
What do you think of cheerleaders?
Wanting to go to olympics..play girls or boys
how can i gain alot of speed to be in the olympics!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
How to be in the olympics!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!??!??
Who is your favorite gymnast ever
will nastia luikin be in the 2012 olympics
what sport is canada worst at in the olympics
Why does the United States bid for just about every Olympics?
can a freshman try out for the varsity track and field or cross country team
IM A GYMNAST AND I NEED TO KNOW HOW TO INSERT A TAMPON
What do you think of the 2014 Sochi Olympic Games?
Am I making good progress in gymnastics
is archery going to be in the 2012 olympics
wat should i be wen i grow up can not make up my mine should i be a track star in the olympics or be a lawyer
What happened to Skater Chad Muska?
What kind of questions do I ask during an interview with an olympic athlete who lost??
how can i easily & quickly get my back handspring
bar sink forums
,
bathroom sink faucet forums
,
cement companies forums
,
entry doors forums
,
gooseneck trailers forums
,
health spa forums
,
hydraulic systems forums
,
jetted shower forums
,
kohler faucet forums
,
marble and granite tile forums
,
sink cabinets forums
,
credit express forums
,
core bit forums
,
conveyor belt forums
,
convection oven forums
,
color steel forums
,
citric acid forums
,
citibank loan forums
,
christmas light forums
,
ball valve forums
,
ball mill forums
,
aluminum ladders forums
,
aluminium foil forums
,
advertising materials forums
,
adhesive tape forums
,
hydraulic press forums
,
health insurance virginia forums
,
gasket maker forums
,
fire hose forums
,
electric drill forums
,
decorative wall forums
,
crisis of credit forums
,
pump truck forums
,
polishing disc forums
,
plumbing system forums
,
pendant lamp forums
,
nfl jersey forums
,
mortgage interest rates forums
,
marble machine forums
,
low iron forums
,
lighting fixture forums
,
lcd tv monitor forums
,
wholesale caps forums
,
weight lose forums
,
water pump forums
,
usaa insurance forums
,
tower crane forums
,
temporary health insurance forums
,
spray paint forums
,
rolling machine forums
,
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
You can post new topics in this forum You can reply to topics in this forum You can edit your posts in this forum You can delete your posts in this forum You can vote in polls in this forum
|
|
|